£327 tramping 6 days

orys:

Ex Haulier:
I think your getting a bit confused. I live and work here, i pay taxes here so if i wanted to see a doctor here i can. I keep a house in Spain, if i take my car down there, there is no requirment to register it there if it’s only there for three months. I have private medical insurance that i have never needed to use and i go to the dentist in Spain which i pay for. I contribute in both countries, i sponge off no one.

Well, I am a bit confused because your situation in Spain is perfectly the same as mine in UK, and 95% of Poles in Britain I know. Yet in one of the many “anti-polish” threads some time ago you were expressing your views on that and, to shorten it in polite way, you weren’t too happy about Poles living in UK…

So how it is with you? Is it just that it’s OK for Britons to choose their life in another country, but it is not OK for Poles?

^^^+1 :slight_smile:

The Sarge:

orys:

Ex Haulier:
I think your getting a bit confused. I live and work here, i pay taxes here so if i wanted to see a doctor here i can. I keep a house in Spain, if i take my car down there, there is no requirment to register it there if it’s only there for three months. I have private medical insurance that i have never needed to use and i go to the dentist in Spain which i pay for. I contribute in both countries, i sponge off no one.

Well, I am a bit confused because your situation in Spain is perfectly the same as mine in UK, and 95% of Poles in Britain I know. Yet in one of the many “anti-polish” threads some time ago you were expressing your views on that and, to shorten it in polite way, you weren’t too happy about Poles living in UK…

So how it is with you? Is it just that it’s OK for Britons to choose their life in another country, but it is not OK for Poles?

^^^+1 :slight_smile:

:smiley: :smiley:

The turkeys vote in favour of christmas.

Oh Dear another ■■■■■ Fest…

Ex Haulier:
The turkeys vote in favour of christmas.

Double standards.

If you do it, it’s good, if other do the same - it’s not.

You should be a political party spin doctor. Never let the truth get in the way of a story eh ?. I haven’t emigrated to Spain, i live here in the UK. Any polish people with the funds to come and spend three months a year here are more than welcome to do so. By the way i haven’t noticed a couple of million brits heading off to poland to work for free for the experience, but maybe you know better.

What I find funny is the few polish people I’ve met and worked with have all said the same things…
I came here for work as none in Poland
I don’t like this country and don’t wish to live here long term, only till I have enough saved to go back home and buy a house
I have sent money home to family as they struggle with what they earn

Now, at the risk of sounding anti polish(I’m not as such) that is very different to any Brit I know has left this ■■■■ hole of a country for something BETTER. it is a very common theme that we move for one or more of the following reasons…
Too much crime
Not enough work since influx of foreigners(not just poles) meaning life gets tougher
Uk weather is crap
Young generation of uk is out of control and the country is ■■■■■■ for the long term future

They’re just a few reasons uk people leave, the difference is orys we want to leave for different reasons your lot want to come! If we struggled to fill basic labour jobs I’d be more then happy to let people in to help but everywhere I go the foreigners are there and it gets the back up of the working class or at least the ones I know :smiley: I have had many a stand off with non English people when I am in a customer situation because we can’t communicate it drives me mad :laughing:
Anyway I think you come across alright compared with the polish I’ve met, the Bulgarians are far worse then the poles in my opinion but polish get a hard stick cause they were the first to come in their thousands. I don’t have anything against you or the polish I nailed one I worked with once she was hot and couldn’t get enough :smiley: :sunglasses: but please don’t compare your reasons for coming here as the same for ours leaving…you pesky poles forced us out :laughing: :stuck_out_tongue:

Ex Haulier:
You should be a political party spin doctor. Never let the truth get in the way of a story eh ?.

Eh, I can’t stand up with your proffesionalism on that field…

I haven’t emigrated to Spain, i live here in the UK.

And keeping your second home in Spain, spending there up to three months at time. It is all in your posts. It’s just you interpreting this facts to show how better you are than me. Sorry, you are not. In fact you live in both places, only Britain is your “centre of vital interest” (I am not sure if it’s the proper translation of that legal term, it’s (in simply way) the place when you spend most of your time and where do you pay your taxes), but you are NOT considered by Spaniards as a tourist.

I am sorry that I am spoiling a great picture of yourself you have if you mind, the “contribute in two countries, sponge none” one: you are also a migrant. If you think migration is bad, you are bad yourself. Face it.

Don’t be silly as well when it comes to the other services - somehow I doubt you will be calling London Fire Brigade when there will be fire in your place. And it has to be keep ready all the time, not only when your home goes on fire. Do you think your private insurance pays for that the Spanish firemans are on call on the time to keep you, amongst other, safe? Off course not, it’s Spanish taxpayers who pay the fireman’s wages. And, as you clearly said, you pay your taxes in Britain.

You said it clearly - you spent a lot of time in Spain, using Spanish infrastructure and services, yet you pay your taxes in UK. Sorry, but I can’t see how you are better than me - I live here, work here, use British infrastructure and pay for it in my (quite high) taxes. And go to Poland only for holidays, as a regular tourist, except that I stay with friends or family on most occasions.

BTW: Do you know that you might be causing some genuine problems for local people over there as well? For example influx of Britons causes property prices to go up despite general tendencies on the local market and economical situation. Therefore young people cannot afford their first homes, families can’t afford to move to the bigger ones etc. I don’t know exactly how situation looks in Spain at the moment, but last time I was in France, I bought a French paper and it was an article about it in it. And it wasn’t the first one I saw on that subject, there was even article on that in the Times some time ago.

See, all emigration - temporary or full time, it does not matter - causes some effects to the local community. Some effects are positive, and some are negative.

In case of Britons having second homes in Sunny places (or moving there for their happy retirements) there are good things like them spending their money earned in Britain and bad - like them driving up property prices on a local market.

The same with Eastern European emigration here: we do cause more competetivness on the job market, but Britain also benefits from us here - for example because we put more to the jar than take out of it.

Any polish people with the funds to come and spend three months a year here are more than welcome to do so.

Can you tell me what is the time limit acceptable for you? :wink:

By the way i haven’t noticed a couple of million brits heading off to poland to work for free for the experience, but maybe you know better.

I haven’t either, but I noticed some. Much more than you propably think.

As for “free work”, as I clearly stated, I was talking about this forum, which, just happens, is about working in UK, not Poland. This is because when I do some comparisions, unlike you I just do not pick some handy facts from where it is convienient to me, so if I talk about spoiling BRITISH market, I take both examples from this country.

OllieNotts:
I don’t like this country and don’t wish to live here long term, only till I have enough saved to go back home and buy a house
I have sent money home to family as they struggle with what they earn

See, the recent analysys of the Polish migrations shows that although that was true, it’s no longer the case - the Poland is the only country in Europe which constantly had economical growth over the period of the crisis. Wages went up significantly, there is plenty of work if you want to work, there are big projects - like huge investments toward EURO 2012 etc.

it’s simply no longer economically viable to work here for your family back home, as the difference in wages is eaten by need to run two households - one here for the working parent, and other there for his family.

I haven’t met any Pole doing that for about two years, altough that was true in the past.

But in the past the situation was different: when I came here in 2006, I spoke poor English and the paint on my driving license was barely dry, I got work straight away, and agency (one only!) was phoning me every day offering a choice of variuous shifts and asking if I don’t have any friends wanting to work for them, nobody will tell me that I stole anybody’s job. There WAS genuine shortage of drivers obviously, at least in Glasgow. So the extra workers weren’t so problematic (in fact, I was wondering how on earth you managed before 2004 without all that Polish cleaners, plumbers, builders, drivers and waiters…)

So this is why I keep involved in all this discussions: your view on the situation is often outdated or wrong, you just stick to some old assumption and when situation changed, you still stick to it using it to attack migration. But just think: Britan has changed dramatically and the situation here in 2011 is for sure extremally different from situation here in 2007. If Britain changed so much, why do you assumed that Polish immigration hasn’t? Poland changed, Britain changed, so imigration changed as well. I am not trying to tell you what you should think about this subject, but I am just taking care that you have a right picture. Then you draw your own conclusions, and as far as I’ve been in these discussions on several occasions, it seems that we are actually thinking the same - if only we know the same facts.

Now, at the risk of sounding anti polish(I’m not as such) that is very different to any Brit I know has left this [zb] hole of a country for something BETTER.

So this is exactly the reason the Poles are coming here: sadly, Britiain is still BETTER than Poland on many fields (but as for workmarket and economical situation, it changes rapidly).

it is a very common theme that we move for one or more of the following reasons…
Too much crime

But Police and Legal System is much better in tackling it thatn their Polish counterparts.

Not enough work since influx of foreigners(not just poles) meaning life gets tougher

Believe or not, but Poland has the same problem - Chinese, Vietnamese, Ukrainian…

Uk weather is crap

But has some advantages. Many of my friends are happy that you don’t have to shovel 3 feets of snow off your car and driveway every day for two-three months in a year. I love winter, but I don’t like when it’s too hot, therefore British weather has some advantages for me as well…

Young generation of uk is out of control and the country is [zb] for the long term future

Well, I can say only one thing: they have only themselves to blame. Do you know that on last elections not a single of my British friends went to vote? And I thouht that it’s bad in Poland on that field…

They’re just a few reasons uk people leave, the difference is orys we want to leave for different reasons your lot want to come!

I hope you can now see, that the differences are in fact minor. The main difference is that we have different point of view, but the reasons are quite the same.

If we struggled to fill basic labour jobs I’d be more then happy to let people in to help but everywhere I go the foreigners are there and it gets the back up of the working class or at least the ones I know :smiley: I have had many a stand off with non English people when I am in a customer situation because we can’t communicate it drives me mad :laughing:

See, the problem is that you invited us when you really needed a workforce, and now we are already there. Noone was expecting the credit crunch and Polish workers are now competing with a British ones. And although I don’t want to sound anti-British, it seems to me than on average the Poles has better attitude towards work - it’s propably because that we are used to hard times, even the youngest remember the hard times of the transformation (our situation in 90s was far worse than what you now experiencing in Britain) while your people are spoiled by the relative luxury they lived on for years.

Anyway I think you come across alright compared with the polish I’ve met, the Bulgarians are far worse then the poles in my opinion but polish get a hard stick cause they were the first to come in their thousands.

Thanks for the nice words, and I have to admit there are some Poles that I sometimes just keep my mouth shout as I don’t want to be recognized as a one of them. I think there are such people in every nation.

I do also understand why we are always on the fork, I try to explain the Polish point of view, but I think it’s valid for the most of the Eastern European countires.

I don’t have anything against you or the polish I nailed one I worked with once she was hot and couldn’t get enough :smiley: :sunglasses: but please don’t compare your reasons for coming here as the same for ours leaving…you pesky poles forced us out :laughing: :stuck_out_tongue:

I tried to show that the reasons are much less different than you think. And AFAIK the British were emigrating to other countries much earlier than 2004, so please don’t put the whole blame on us :wink:

*could you explain the word “pesky” to me? I can see that it’s not always offensive, but I don’t really get it’s second meaning (and I am optimistically assuming that you are not trying to insult me :stuck_out_tongue:)

Ha ha you make me laugh, pesky is like annoying :stuck_out_tongue:
So I did say at the beginning in my experience and you said I was right but things have changed. It isn’t just the poles to I agree, lots of Arab types on security gates who can talk worse then the polish :unamused:
The uk is beyond repair now, by the time I die it won’t even be a White British country, what’s left of it anyway. If and when I’m in a position to move away I will, I like Scotland a lot would love to move up there despite them hating English deep down through their jealousy :smiley: I would learn their language and fit within their traditions though instead of demanding I do what I want like some cultures have done here. You’d think we’d of learnt after powel’s mistakes of the 50’s :unamused:

That might be a bit off topic, but as you mentioned history I thought I will ask:

I’ve been listening recently on BBC 4 an reportage on Jamaican immigration…

I wondered how it was: you told the Polish pilots who fought in RAF to bugger off, as there is no work for them in these hard times, yet just after the war started you invited thousands of Jamaicans here…

Why they were welcomed here, while Poles, who fought for you and had no free country (Stalin was ruling Poland and the soldiers of RAF could be even shot dead for “spying”) to go back weren’t? Is that because you “owed” that to the Jamaicans as they were part of commonwealth?

I know my questiion is from strictly Polish point of view, but I just want to understand…

Cheap labour to rebuild but the older lads could tell you more I’m not getting into that :smiley:
Same principle though, open the gates and get plenty of cheap labour to fill the jobs but it didn’t quite work out that way. Anyone who helped in the war should of had more right to stay then the gollys but as you say maybe it’s the commonwealth thing I am too young to know inns and outs.

OllieNotts:
Cheap labour to rebuild but the older lads could tell you more I’m not getting into that :smiley:
Same principle though, open the gates and get plenty of cheap labour to fill the jobs but it didn’t quite work out that way. Anyone who helped in the war should of had more right to stay then the gollys but as you say maybe it’s the commonwealth thing I am too young to know inns and outs.

Thanks. As for the main topic of our biggest branch of our off topic: I am afraid, that Muslims will dominate not only Britain but the whole Europe by the time I will be retired… The math says it all: they have on average three times more kids than white people… I heard that most popular British name given to boys last year was Muhammad…

I have nothing against Muslims, but I would like them to have nothing against our lifestyle as well and to try to fit when they come to Europe…

So, this is another example, that we all have the same problems :wink:

True, hate all religions cause they’re all borrocks!! :smiley:
Funny thing is my dad is Dublin born and bread and been here so long he moans about foreigners taking our jobs etc…then I remind him how ironic it is what he’s saying seeing as unlike me he isn’t English or even British either :laughing: he said that don’t matter as the Irish built our roads lol

orys:

Ex Haulier:
You should be a political party spin doctor. Never let the truth get in the way of a story eh ?.

Eh, I can’t stand up with your proffesionalism on that field…

I haven’t emigrated to Spain, i live here in the UK.

And keeping your second home in Spain, spending there up to three months at time. It is all in your posts. It’s just you interpreting this facts to show how better you are than me. Sorry, you are not. In fact you live in both places, only Britain is your “centre of vital interest” (I am not sure if it’s the proper translation of that legal term, it’s (in simply way) the place when you spend most of your time and where do you pay your taxes), but you are NOT considered by Spaniards as a tourist.

I am sorry that I am spoiling a great picture of yourself you have if you mind, the “contribute in two countries, sponge none” one: you are also a migrant. If you think migration is bad, you are bad yourself. Face it.

Don’t be silly as well when it comes to the other services - somehow I doubt you will be calling London Fire Brigade when there will be fire in your place. And it has to be keep ready all the time, not only when your home goes on fire. Do you think your private insurance pays for that the Spanish firemans are on call on the time to keep you, amongst other, safe? Off course not, it’s Spanish taxpayers who pay the fireman’s wages. And, as you clearly said, you pay your taxes in Britain.

You said it clearly - you spent a lot of time in Spain, using Spanish infrastructure and services, yet you pay your taxes in UK. Sorry, but I can’t see how you are better than me - I live here, work here, use British infrastructure and pay for it in my (quite high) taxes. And go to Poland only for holidays, as a regular tourist, except that I stay with friends or family on most occasions.

BTW: Do you know that you might be causing some genuine problems for local people over there as well? For example influx of Britons causes property prices to go up despite general tendencies on the local market and economical situation. Therefore young people cannot afford their first homes, families can’t afford to move to the bigger ones etc. I don’t know exactly how situation looks in Spain at the moment, but last time I was in France, I bought a French paper and it was an article about it in it. And it wasn’t the first one I saw on that subject, there was even article on that in the Times some time ago.

See, all emigration - temporary or full time, it does not matter - causes some effects to the local community. Some effects are positive, and some are negative.

In case of Britons having second homes in Sunny places (or moving there for their happy retirements) there are good things like them spending their money earned in Britain and bad - like them driving up property prices on a local market.

The same with Eastern European emigration here: we do cause more competetivness on the job market, but Britain also benefits from us here - for example because we put more to the jar than take out of it.

Any polish people with the funds to come and spend three months a year here are more than welcome to do so.

Can you tell me what is the time limit acceptable for you? :wink:

By the way i haven’t noticed a couple of million brits heading off to poland to work for free for the experience, but maybe you know better.

I haven’t either, but I noticed some. Much more than you propably think.

As for “free work”, as I clearly stated, I was talking about this forum, which, just happens, is about working in UK, not Poland. This is because when I do some comparisions, unlike you I just do not pick some handy facts from where it is convienient to me, so if I talk about spoiling BRITISH market, I take both examples from this country.

You do come out with some right rcap. I haven’t done anyone out of a house in Spain. There are about half a million brand new and unsold ones where my house is and what’s more they have halved in price in the last couple of years. I pay my rates for 12 months of the year in Spain, not just the three i am there. If you think you bring so many benefits why do you reckon it was that the germans didn’t throw the doors open and welcome you all straightaway ?. I presume that as you seem to favour an open door policy you think the doors should be thrown open to all those chaps who are trying to hide on trucks at Calais, or should the door be bolted now you are in ?.

Ex Haulier:
You do come out with some right rcap. I haven’t done anyone out of a house in Spain. There are about half a million brand new and unsold ones where my house is and what’s more they have halved in price in the last couple of years. I pay my rates for 12 months of the year in Spain, not just the three i am there.

But you don’t pay taxes there, yet you live there for 1/4 of the year. And house prices was just an example to show that emigrants always have some influence on the local community. Go to Plockton in Scotland and see how people, who bought there holiday homes influenced on local community - the place is dead outside the season, as the homes are empty… You ALWAYS have impact on the local community - that or different way.

(please note: I did not wrote “what a load of crap”. This is called “culture of discussion”).

If you think you bring so many benefits why do you reckon it was that the germans didn’t throw the doors open and welcome you all straightaway ?

Well, last time we discussed the subject, I linked to the article where it was written that they consider it as a mistake now, as they struggle for workforce and they beg Poles to go and work to them, but now is too late, as there is no point to Poles to work for them any more, as in the trades they need Poles can earn more home…

Somehow I am not surprised that you ignored that fact, as it does not fit into your picture of the world.

. I presume that as you seem to favour an open door policy you think the doors should be thrown open to all those chaps who are trying to hide on trucks at Calais, or should the door be bolted now you are in ?.

I am all for open policy within European Union, as for the rest of the world the cultural differences should be taken into account.

Cultural differences ?. So is that yes or no ?.

Thank you for informing us of the germany situation. I have to say i find it rather hard to believe that thriving germany pays less than poland or britain. I guess you think that we should be grateful that so many of you have chosen to come here.

You seem to ignore the fact that i pay for my house in spain for twelve months of the year, yet seem to think i should pay income tax when i have no income there. Your argument does not make sense.

I think we will always be ‘Poles apart’ on this subject. (or should that be depart?)

Ex Haulier:
Cultural differences ?. So is that yes or no ?.

Thank you for informing us of the germany situation. I have to say i find it rather hard to believe that thriving germany pays less than poland or britain. I guess you think that we should be grateful that so many of you have chosen to come here.

You seem to ignore the fact that i pay for my house in spain for twelve months of the year, yet seem to think i should pay income tax when i have no income there. Your argument does not make sense.

Make perfect sense to me :unamused: What hes saying is you live there & must use their services that local peoples tax money helps to pay for but you yourself don’t pay taxes so therefor your not contributing!!

tyler4164:
Make perfect sense to me :unamused: What hes saying is you live there & must use their services that local peoples tax money helps to pay for but you yourself don’t pay taxes so therefor your not contributing!!

OR, if you feel you ARE contributing, then so is Orys and all other legal migrant workers in the UK. It does seem to make sense to me too…