Was I Right ?

ady1:

Mike-C:

Spardo:
Equality means just that, if it had been done (first time) to a man by a man, there would have been no report and no sacking.

I wouldn’t be so sure. I forgot this one, just before xmas a guy in our warehouse was fooling around with another guy wrestling and he tried to pull his trousers down to embarrass him. Sacked, straight away !!

yes and years ago it used to be part of iniation party when you came out of your time as a apprentice, trousers dragged off , chased round the shop floor by the women on the bun trollies , if you got caught shaving foam rubbed into your zb ,. did any one get sacked for it NO, did any of us complain NO, because it was tradition , it had happened to my grandad , my dad, and every other apprentice for years and years , now thered be uproar , sackings , court cases . are things better now , i dont think so

Ady years ago children where sent up chimneys to clean them. Would you send yours up now? If you think any sort of physical initiation ceromonies are ok try and explain it to me in terms that a parent of one of the many who killed themselves at Deepcut barracks might understand?
Lady P did get one thing wrong in her post though.

Last week a driver was sacked because of me

He got sacked because he thought he could do what he liked to who he liked to do it to. I would of loved to see his face when he went home and told his missus why he got sacked.
Just to indicate to you that i’m not in the least PC, if the women on the bun trollies had tried to do that to me they’d get the same smack a guy would get if he tried to do it. Woman or no woman.

And perhaps we should welcome back cholera , TB and other diseases fatal to young children. How about taking away seatbelts and airbags. As for bunks and night heaters , out they go. Along with motorways and cheap airlines. And lets not forget a huge welcome back for our old friend Asbestos… After all “thats the way things were” and nobody complained , it was the good old days when you could beat your wife nightly, and did she complain, of course not…

We live in a progressive world where we try to “improve” on things.

Spardo and Ady you seem to be living in some kind of “Monty Python” sketch… :open_mouth:

Mike C …Spot on right through mate… :smiley: :wink:

yes and years ago it used to be part of iniation party when you came out of your time as a apprentice, trousers dragged off , chased round the shop floor by the women on the bun trollies , if you got caught shaving foam rubbed into your zb ,. did any one get sacked for it NO, did any of us complain NO, because it was tradition , it had happened to my grandad , my dad, and every other apprentice for years and years , now thered be uproar , sackings , court cases . are things better now , i dont think so.

I have to say I have never had men taking my trousers off at work or/and having shaving foam rubbed into you meat and two veg by them. I have seen some web sites that deal with people who like that sort of thing.

I would have thought people might have gone along with it more because in a room full of strange new workers and people, well a nasty catch 22 situation. I cannot imagine anyone likes this sort of joke stuff done to them. I wouldn’t go on a national web forum and say I like men taking me trousers of and rubbing shaving foam into me woman disappointer, I’d keep that quite.

Thankfully the worst that ever happen to me was going for a long stand, but in the end I found one and also a a left handed screwdriver, but it would make me cringe having some no brain trying to trick me and have fun at my expense. They were always the ones pumping up their tyre’s afterwork for some reason.

In this day and age, no its not on, well it wasn’t then, but workers move around a lot, short contracts, its not the same as going into a job for lifetime, so it has no place in today. I would love to see a Poles face as you removed his pants and started trying to shave him.

As for LP, well she asked an opinion, so she got some different answers, but I feel the outcome from the post is very anti-bullying, so alls not lost in this daft country. If someone tried to do the same thing to my missus at work, then

A. She could deal with it.
B. Her workmates would deal with it
C. I would deal with it

My missus is lucky, LP maybe the only woman at this company and she should have been put in this position were even though she is the victim, she will be made to look like the bad person. I hope her work mates are like the one where my missus works.

Andy

ady1:
i take the hint , its your way , your views or not at all

And where the hell did you get that choice piece of paranoia from? Good grief man. I’m simply pointing out that anyone who posts their views on a public forum must be prepared to have them challenged. Which is kind of what you said to Lady P in the first place…Funny how you don’t like it when the same thing is applied to you. :unamused:

Please, please will someone explain to me why exactly it is that every time Lucy expresses a view on something which is is contrary to another poster or about which she feels strongly, that translates to “It’s your view or nothing on TruckNet then” ■■? Or do you just have a problem with assertive women? You and all the others who love to pull this line out…you know who you are…

Somebody explain this once and for all, please.

drew128:
My missus is lucky, LP maybe the only woman at this company and she should have been put in this position were even though she is the victim, she will be made to look like the bad person. I hope her work mates are like the one where my missus works.

That’s what I find so sad about LP’s position. I’m the only woman on our side of the company I work for (the TM is female, as are many of the office staff, but the setup is such that they are a good way away on the other side of the dock and don’t have much to do with what happens in the yard), and have had small run-ins of a hands on nature with one of our yard fitters who doesn’t always know where to draw the line. Whilst they’ve been of a kind I could deal with myself, I know for a fact that I have back-up from my workmates should I need it - as was borne out by an incident where our FM (different bloke, and known quietly as “Dad”, 'nuf said…) took his verbal discrimination too far last week.

I know that if the yard fitter ever did go to the excesses Lady P has described I would have more trouble getting to report him before anyone else did than stopping him getting dealt with. Except possibly stopping him from getting lynched. Hell, I can’t even have a common or garden domestic in the comfort of my own cab, by phone, without someone giving me chapter on verse on why I should get shot of my long-suffering other half, for god’s sake! Even when I’m quite blatantly in the wrong!

The good firms have a “famiily” atmosphere like that. In my case it’s like having 30 big brothers to look after me. And I look after them where I can too. It’s a completely equal thing, as it should be…Which is why I’m so sad for LP that she isn’t blessed with the same where she works.

Mike-C:
The ONLY excuse for bending a bird over is if its your bird and she wants you to!

would have to take issue with that - if she was somebody else’s “bird” but she wanted you to that’s fair enough :wink: :laughing:

Ahhh…But then she’d be being “yours” for the duration, so Mike’s comment stands… :stuck_out_tongue: :stuck_out_tongue: :stuck_out_tongue:

montana man:
And perhaps we should welcome back cholera , TB and other diseases fatal to young children. How about taking away seatbelts and airbags. As for bunks and night heaters , out they go. Along with motorways and cheap airlines. And lets not forget a huge welcome back for our old friend Asbestos… After all “thats the way things were” and nobody complained , it was the good old days when you could beat your wife nightly, and did she complain, of course not…

We live in a progressive world where we try to “improve” on things.

Spardo and Ady you seem to be living in some kind of “Monty Python” sketch… :open_mouth:

My God what a load of hysteria over horseplay in the yard. And that is all that it was in the original post:

Lady P:
1 of the drivers bent me over from behind, or tried too I did thump him and “asked him not to do that,”

and all that I based my opinion on. I don’t go to chat rooms and I didn’t know there was a history. When I did I revised my opinion. But strewth. Cholera, TB, kids up chimneys. Disgusting comparisons. And if you think you are disappointed Lucy, it is nothing to what I feel. You had all the facts, I didn’t, yet you chose to make a personal attack.

Get a sense of perspective.

Spardo:
My God what a load of hysteria over horseplay in the yard. And that is all that it was in the original post:

Ha ! You’re some guy Spardo. How about i ‘horseplay’ with your missus?
After all its just a laugh eh?

Spardo:
My God what a load of hysteria over horseplay in the yard. And that is all that it was in the original post:

The problem as I see it is that one persons ‘horseplay’ is another persons bullying. This ‘horseplay’ usually has one victim and they often don’t speak out against it for fear of making their life at work even worse. There is often a reason why someone is chosen as the recipient of the ‘horseplay’ and it is usually because they are deemed to be in some way weaker and the instigator of the ‘horseplay’ is usually the loudest mouth there and is desperate to appear to be ‘one of the lads.’

A few years ago in a Germany there were around ten drivers on a night out and we had enjoyed a good evening visiting a bar or six. One of the group was LOUD and very, very, annoying and three or four of us were sitting at the bar trying to avoid him as we had all reached the same conclusion, he was a total [zb]. Desperate to be one of the lads he decided I should be a victim of his ‘horseplay’ and started grabbing me and generally being very annoying, all the while looking round at some of the others for approval. He didn’t really know me from Adam, as I didn’t know him, and he was getting a little put out that I took exception to his ‘horseplay’ and wouldn’t join in so increased his efforts to get me to go along. In order not to disappoint him I introduced him to some ‘horseplay’ between a bar stool and his face/skull. At this point, from his new found position on the floor, he decided he didn’t want to play any more, which was a bit of a surprise as he was well up for ‘horseplay’ before that. A ‘bit of horseplay’ can easily get out of hand.

A bit of banter and larking about between people who know each other very well and who each give as good as they get is acceptable, in any other case it is bullying. Bully’s can dish it out but they can’t take it, they can’t back track quick enough when you stand up to them. What happened to Lady P is at least bullying and at worst ■■■■■■ assault, if that sort of thing happened to kids at school we would not accept it so why should we put it down to a bit of horseplay it in the workplace?

Although some of us replying did have more knowledge of the incident than was in the first post there is more than enough information there to realise that it was totally unacceptable and there is no excuse for it.

I notice a couple of posts mention that he maybe shouldn’t have been sacked because he has a wife and kids. I don’t really see that we should worry about them as they were obviously far from his thoughts when he started trying to hump a fellow driver.

In order not to disappoint him I introduced him to some ‘horseplay’ between a bar stool and his face/skull. At this point, from his new found position on the floor, he decided he didn’t want to play any more, which was a bit of a surprise as he was well up for ‘horseplay’ before that. A ‘bit of horseplay’ can easily get out of hand.

:laughing: :laughing: :wink:

You spoil sport

Very true though, well said.

Do you need a stool for horseplay, I am not sure I would be the right height.

Andy

Mike-C:

ady1:

Mike-C:

Spardo:
Equality means just that, if it had been done (first time) to a man by a man, there would have been no report and no sacking.

I wouldn’t be so sure. I forgot this one, just before xmas a guy in our warehouse was fooling around with another guy wrestling and he tried to pull his trousers down to embarrass him. Sacked, straight away !!

yes and years ago it used to be part of iniation party when you came out of your time as a apprentice, trousers dragged off , chased round the shop floor by the women on the bun trollies , if you got caught shaving foam rubbed into your zb ,. did any one get sacked for it NO, did any of us complain NO, because it was tradition , it had happened to my grandad , my dad, and every other apprentice for years and years , now thered be uproar , sackings , court cases . are things better now , i dont think so

Ady years ago children where sent up chimneys to clean them. Would you send yours up now? If you think any sort of physical initiation ceromonies are ok try and explain it to me in terms that a parent of one of the many who killed themselves at Deepcut barracks might understand?
Lady P did get one thing wrong in her post though.

Last week a driver was sacked because of me

He got sacked because he thought he could do what he liked to who he liked to do it to. I would of loved to see his face when he went home and told his missus why he got sacked.
Just to indicate to you that i’m not in the least PC, if the women on the bun trollies had tried to do that to me they’d get the same smack a guy would get if he tried to do it. Woman or no woman.

why hit them , you knew it was comming , you took it and got on with it, the following day you had a laugh about it and moved on, no one got reported, no one got sacked or anything , now its just any angle to drop someone in it
whenever i see my old mates there always on about the great laughs we had, no one ever speaks about the great laughs they have now because everyone ones to frightened to have one, if we did half the things we did then, now , wed never see the light of day again, are things really that much better now, im not convinced

drew128:

yes and years ago it used to be part of iniation party when you came out of your time as a apprentice, trousers dragged off , chased round the shop floor by the women on the bun trollies , if you got caught shaving foam rubbed into your zb ,. did any one get sacked for it NO, did any of us complain NO, because it was tradition , it had happened to my grandad , my dad, and every other apprentice for years and years , now thered be uproar , sackings , court cases . are things better now , i dont think so.

I have to say I have never had men taking my trousers off at work or/and having shaving foam rubbed into you meat and two veg by them. I have seen some web sites that deal with people who like that sort of thing.

I would have thought people might have gone along with it more because in a room full of strange new workers and people, well a nasty catch 22 situation. I cannot imagine anyone likes this sort of joke stuff done to them. I wouldn’t go on a national web forum and say I like men taking me trousers of and rubbing shaving foam into me woman disappointer, I’d keep that quite.

Thankfully the worst that ever happen to me was going for a long stand, but in the end I found one and also a a left handed screwdriver, but it would make me cringe having some no brain trying to trick me and have fun at my expense. They were always the ones pumping up their tyre’s afterwork for some reason.

In this day and age, no its not on, well it wasn’t then, but workers move around a lot, short contracts, its not the same as going into a job for lifetime, so it has no place in today. I would love to see a Poles face as you removed his pants and started trying to shave him.

As for LP, well she asked an opinion, so she got some different answers, but I feel the outcome from the post is very anti-bullying, so alls not lost in this daft country. If someone tried to do the same thing to my missus at work, then

A. She could deal with it.
B. Her workmates would deal with it
C. I would deal with it

My missus is lucky, LP maybe the only woman at this company and she should have been put in this position were even though she is the victim, she will be made to look like the bad person. I hope her work mates are like the one where my missus works.

Andy

chased by women on the bun trollies, try reading it properly before you attempt to take the ■■■■ :unamused: as for woman dissapointer yep your right there the ex and a few others will vouch for that , ive definetly dissapointed them, theyve all tried to mould me into something im not and eventually gave up .
but luckily enough for me theres still enough desparate women out there to keep me going :laughing: :laughing:

ady1:
you knew it was comming , you took it and got on with it,

And a lot of people would much rather it hadn’t happened to them but they kept quiet and ‘took it’ because there wasn’t much in the way of an alternative. If they hadn’t taken it their work life would have been made miserable by the same bullies who dished out the first bit of fun. There are well documented accounts of people being forced out of a job they enjoyed because of this practice but even that pales into insignificance when compared to those who took their own life after suffering a bit of initiation fun.

No matter how you dress it up a mob against one unwilling victim is, in my opinion unacceptable no matter how traditional or funny the mob think it is.

Spardo:

montana man:
And perhaps we should welcome back cholera , TB and other diseases fatal to young children. How about taking away seatbelts and airbags. As for bunks and night heaters , out they go. Along with motorways and cheap airlines. And lets not forget a huge welcome back for our old friend Asbestos… After all “thats the way things were” and nobody complained , it was the good old days when you could beat your wife nightly, and did she complain, of course not…

We live in a progressive world where we try to “improve” on things.

Spardo and Ady you seem to be living in some kind of “Monty Python” sketch… :open_mouth:

My God what a load of hysteria over horseplay in the yard. And that is all that it was in the original post:

Lady P:
1 of the drivers bent me over from behind, or tried too I did thump him and “asked him not to do that,”

I’m sorry, but that is NOT horseplay in this day and age. It is ■■■■■■ assault. So where exactly do you draw the line Spardo? What point would an assault have to reach before you decided that enough was enough when you were a manager? Would he have had to stick his hand between her legs? Would he have had to rip her pants down? Would even a ■■■■ be ok if it was in your yard…because, hey, it’s just horseplay, and in the interests of “equality” it should be allowed…god forbid, after all, that you be seen to defend a driver because another driver chose to take advantage of his superior strength and help himself to her body knowing that she wasn’t a bloke and therefore far less likely to floor him as a result.

Personally, I don’t think equality is about anally reducing everything to it’s lowest common denominator. It’s about affording equal respect to all employees regardless of gender. Yes, there will be situations where things will happen between a male and a female which would be unlikely to occur between two males…you can’t just shy away from dealing with it because it’s outside your comfort zone to be seen to back the weaker driver. To treat all drivers with equal respect means to accept that biological differences will cause such situations to arise, and that they should be dealt with using respect as your number one priority. Helping yourself to another driver’s body in an aggressively ■■■■■■ manner - as is patently obvious from LP’s first post, since I cannot think of any instance where this action would NOT constitute an aggressively ■■■■■■ incident - is a breach of the victim’s respect whichever way you look at it.

and all that I based my opinion on. I don’t go to chat rooms and I didn’t know there was a history. When I did I revised my opinion. But strewth. Cholera, TB, kids up chimneys. Disgusting comparisons. And if you think you are disappointed Lucy, it is nothing to what I feel. You had all the facts, I didn’t, yet you chose to make a personal attack.

I did not make a personal attack, I attacked your opinion, and commented on how it made me feel. As said above, the opening post said enough for me to have had the same view regardless of any other details.To my mind, you had plenty enough facts…but then I suppose that depends on to what extent you think that people have the right to claim ownership of their own bodies. “Bending a woman over” is unacceptable behaviour in this day and age, full stop.

Which is why the comparisons with kids up chimneys are accurate. It was a practice once considered acceptable which is now considered abhorrent.
Treating women’s - or men’s - bodies with violatory contempt in this way was once considered acceptable, now it is abhorrent.
Where exactly is the difference?

Get a sense of perspective.

I have a sense of perspective, thanks. One which says that my body, your body, anyone else’s body is theirs and theirs alone. One which says that to violate that is to demonstrate disrespect in the extreme. One which says that this is 2007, not 1907, and women are no longer forced to accept men’s dismissal of incidents in which physical ■■■■■■■■-motivated contact has occured. One which knows that, if she chose to, LP could take this to a tribunal - or even a court of law - and they would agree and uphold her right.

My perspective is that ■■■■■■ assault in any form, against any gender, is unacceptable. And if you - or your wife - were on the receiving end of such an assault you may suddenly find you agreed, once you’d got over how dirty, violated and physically sick the victim is left to feel.

My personal view…

A certain amount of “horseplay” and banter is the norm amongst drivers,

At work drivers do “take the mickey” out of each other, the point is that this action happened not because Lady P is a driver, but solely because she is a woman This was a “bit of fun” not amongst drivers, but a sexualy motivated action against a woman.

It is unacceptable in the work place, or anywhere else.

Lady P has the right to expect to be safe at work, and not to be threatened/abused/attacked purely because of her gender.

No two ways about this, she did the right thing

I have to say I have never had men taking my trousers off at work or/and having shaving foam rubbed into you meat and two veg by them. I have seen some web sites that deal with people who like that sort of thing.

Errrr…

You couldn’t post some links up,could you. :blush:

Ken.

ady1:
you knew it was comming , you took it and got on with it,

:open_mouth: :open_mouth: :open_mouth: so Lady P should have known that because she was the only woman there she would “Have” to expect this and tolerate it.

Well at least I know to tell my teenage daughter that when she gets her first job that she should “expect” that sort of thing and when it happens she should just take it and tolerate it because after all its just “what happens”.

I was an apprentice once and had my fair share of tricks played on me. You know “go to stores for a long stand, left handed screw driver etc etc”.
Now that is funny and I shared the laugh with the guys about. Yes I knew that was coming but it seems far removed from this incident. Light hearted joking in the workplace is a good thing but any sort of hazing, bullying, ■■■■■■ or racial innuendo is certainly not. Not once during the fun had at my expense was there any form of physical contact other wise I would have retaliated just as the first neanderthal like you who touches my daughter will find out. If she doesn’t take care of them first… :smiley: :wink:

Welcome to the 21st century my friend. Please leave your victorian attitudes at the door… :angry: :angry:

Errrr…

You couldn’t post some links up,could you.

Ken.

Which way do you swing Ken, Gel or Foam?