Testing immigrants

bulldog:
I do want to bring the subject up again on foreign drivers in our country.

I have been warned about my own personal beliefs and predidices so i will try to tame it down.
Alli’d like to know is if any other drivers like me think that immigrants should be put through some sort of test to see if they are willing to adapt to the English way of like before they are granted stay in this country. Like they do in Holland. They have to learn the language over there and learn about the Dutch way of life before theyr’e allowed to stay in the country. Shouldn’t we do the same here before?

Is this such a bad thing to ask?

Now what makes you think that we have a hope in hell of teaching foreigners English when we haven’t been able to get Yorkshire people talking properly yet?

davecsm:

bulldog:
I do want to bring the subject up again on foreign drivers in our country.

I have been warned about my own personal beliefs and predidices so i will try to tame it down.
Alli’d like to know is if any other drivers like me think that immigrants should be put through some sort of test to see if they are willing to adapt to the English way of like before they are granted stay in this country. Like they do in Holland. They have to learn the language over there and learn about the Dutch way of life before theyr’e allowed to stay in the country. Shouldn’t we do the same here before?

Is this such a bad thing to ask?

Now what makes you think that we have a hope in hell of teaching foreigners English when we haven’t been able to get Yorkshire people talking properly yet?

:angry:

We talk properly - it’s the rest of the country that talks funny. :unamused:

jammymutt:
Yes Lucy it is a trucking but Bullys is not about trucking its about airing views on other things untruck related isnt it■■?.

I was thinking the same thing jammy… as it states under the forum heading for Bully’s. “anything but trucking”, is what I think it says.

The problem isn’t with the majority of immigrants in any country. We have a huge immigrant population too. And for the most part they try to fit in, adapt, and respect the way of life here. They don’t usually move because of a dislike for their own culture, its generally for political or religious freedom issues, or to escape poverty. And who can blame them. You’d do the same if it meant a better way of life for you and your family as well. I’ve seen plenty of posts in here about how much better off an ex-pat is since moving to the US than they were in Britain, and plenty of posts from people trying to figure out how to get here… As well as complaints about the language usage, differences in traditions and they way of life here. After all, they chose to come here just as the immigrants in Britain chose to go there. So lets not be too hypocritical.

It’s normal to try to maintain a level of native culture. This may not be a great comparison, but it’s not much different than Patrick wanting to celebrate British holidays and traditions here. It’s meaningless to us but may be important to him. Just like I’d like to celebrate American ones if I lived there. Its the few that don’t keep it private, have a political agenda and try to change the country they move to into what they couldn’t make of their home country that are causing the problems. If you have a problem with the social programs that the UK offers to these immigrants, then take it up with law makers… they’re the ones responsible for that.

It’s a global community … cultures spill over into other cultures, and its always been that way. Ignore what you don’t like and what doesn’t pertain to you. The cultural differences can’t effect you unless you let it. As far as immigrant workers doing the same job for less money, and lowering the standard wage for certain jobs,… its that way everywhere. Keep in mind that what they are paid there seems like a fortune compared to what they had. And I doubt that they even know how much less they make, because if they did, they would be crying discrimination about that too, wouldn’t they? Its the British employers that are exploiting them, not the other way around. And if immigrants can’t speak English, who’s it really hurting… they’re the ones with the communication problem, right?

And just a note on that topic… after doing some research to establish Sadie’s joint citizenship, I’ve found that the immigration procedures in the UK require that anyone filing for residency are required to prove that they can support themselves free of govermental aid for as long as they are living in the UK. If we moved there, I would have to prove that Patricks income was sufficient to support us, or that I’m qualified enough to find a job that can help him support us. We wouldn’t even be entitled to the child allowance. I can’t imagine the laws would be different for immigrants from other countries besides the US, unless you’re talking about immigrants who claim asylum, thats a bit different. But in general, immigration laws are standard, aren’t they? And like the US, they are also implementing an English language exam, though I’m not sure when that takes affect.

Kate Hasler:

jammymutt:
Yes Lucy it is a trucking but Bullys is not about trucking its about airing views on other things untruck related isnt it■■?.

I was thinking the same thing jammy… as it states under the forum heading for Bully’s. “anything but trucking”, is what I think it says.

gurner:
It was posted in the normal section then moved here mate.

Kate Hasler:
Its the few that don’t keep it private, have a political agenda and try to change the country they move to into what they couldn’t make of their home country that are causing the problems.

I couldnt agree more !!!

If you have a problem with the social programs that the UK offers to these immigrants, then take it up with law makers… they’re the ones responsible for that.

People are to scared of bieng branded a racist, which is a term that is used to quickly here.

As far as immigrant workers doing the same job for less money, and lowering the standard wage for certain jobs,… its that way everywhere. Keep in mind that what they are paid there seems like a fortune compared to what they had.

The argument is more directed at the ones that dont work, just simply live off out goverment and take preferential treatment when it comes to housing etc.

And just a note on that topic… after doing some research to establish Sadie’s joint citizenship, I’ve found that the immigration procedures in the UK require that anyone filing for residency are required to prove that they can support themselves free of govermental aid for as long as they are living in the UK. If we moved there, I would have to prove that Patricks income was sufficient to support us, or that I’m qualified enough to find a job that can help him support us.

Not if you come in, in the back of a lorry from calais you wont.

Gurner:
People are to scared of bieng branded a racist, which is a term that is used to quickly here.

I don’t see how it can be racism unless its singling out a specific group of people based on their nation of origin or color of their skin. And the fact is, the governments have it screwed up… benefits should given to the citizens first…and the immigrants should be standing at the end of the line… ALL of them.

The argument is more directed at the ones that dont work, just simply live off out goverment and take preferential treatment when it comes to housing etc.

Aren’t the requirements for benefits the same for everyone? Or do they have lower standards of qualification for immigrants for some reason?

Not if you come in, in the back of a lorry from calais you wont.

So they let people stay and collect benefits even if they’re illegal? As soon as they apply for benefits, the government must be aware that they’re there illegally. I have to say though, its a flaw the US government has as well. The social services programs aren’t allowed to report the immigration status of any applicants… not really sure why, and it doesn’t make any sense.