So not only Eddie Stobart drives trains into UK

Harry Monk:
I must admit I am struggling to make the connection between the conflict between Germany and the USSR in 1939 and the British road transport industry in 2011. :wink:

It was caused by someone with a very vague knowledge of history Harry, but maybe he is biased being half German.

robinhood_1984:
If the UK had of lived up to even less of its commitments 60 years ago Poland would not even exist. Funny that you say you fought for Britain in he war, I see to think that Britain fought on behalf of you?! You may have lived for 50 years under Soviet rule but the alternative was German rule and I dont think 4 or 5 years of German occupation was going too well for you, never mind 50 years of it.

Could this be the Polish national anthem ?.

youtube.com/watch?v=RbvOO4DnReI

Ex Haulier:
Could this be the Polish national anthem ?.

youtube.com/watch?v=RbvOO4DnReI

:laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

Well, this just go’s to show how well Propaganda works , they were fed ■■■■■■■■■ and we were fed ■■■■■■■■■
and what’s really funny, they are still giving all of us BS and it’s the Germans who are still way out in front of everyone !!!

So, lets start a War !!!

Wheel Nut:
It was caused by someone with a very vague knowledge of history Harry, but maybe he is biased being half German.

robinhood_1984:
If the UK had of lived up to even less of its commitments 60 years ago Poland would not even exist. Funny that you say you fought for Britain in he war, I see to think that Britain fought on behalf of you?! You may have lived for 50 years under Soviet rule but the alternative was German rule and I dont think 4 or 5 years of German occupation was going too well for you, never mind 50 years of it.

Biased about what, my support of Britain?! I hardly think so. Orys implied, whether jokingly or not that Poland was intitled to export its labour and transport industry to the west at the detriment of the existing population in those countries, including Britain as recompense for our betrayal of Poland before, during and after WWII. I simply pointed out that Britain only entered WWII to honour the treaty that was in place with Poland at that time everything that happened after that time is irrelivent because the war had already being commited to and talk of Abbeville is irrelevent as it happened the year after Britain decleared war on Germany. War was not decleared on Germany because of their invasion of Russia, Denmark or Yugoslavia, it was because of Germany’s invasion of Poland and everything that happened after that was a direct consequence of that declaration of war. If Britain had really had betrayed Poland they’d have just done nothing as per Czechoslovakia in 1938. So I fail to see how Britain owes Poland anything, the fact I’m half German has nothing to do with it.

I have a few minutes, so I’ll try to answer to some questions:

robinhood_1984:
Biased about what, my support of Britain?! I hardly think so. Orys implied, whether jokingly or not that Poland was intitled to export its labour and transport industry to the west at the detriment of the existing population in those countries, including Britain as recompense for our betrayal of Poland before, during and after WWII.

Just to clarify: this is not what I meant. I mean that you should not be surprised that there are so big differences in development between our countries, which are making that big difference in labour and other costs - as it is a result of the historical events during and after the second world wars, for which Britain was in a big part responsible. It is possible that my English is not good enough to make it clear but it is what I mean. I try to explain it on an example: you decided that Poles are banned from having american cars, and you were all driving big V8 cars and Poles are driving small engined europen cars. Now the petrol prices went up so don’t be suprised that Poles can drive cheaper than you. This is what I mean.

talk of Abbeville is irrelevent as it happened the year after Britain decleared war on Germany.

The Abbeyville conference took place 12th of September 1939, so 12 days after Poland was attacked.
So unless Britain declared war on Germany year before Poland was invaded, or unless you are talking about different Abbeyville conference, you just have no idea about what you are talking about.

If Britain had really had betrayed Poland they’d have just done nothing as per Czechoslovakia in 1938. So I fail to see how Britain owes Poland anything, the fact I’m half German has nothing to do with it.

So what they did which they didn’t when they sold Czechoslovakia to Hitler?
Apart of this silly little war, which is called in British nomenclature “phoney war”. As far as my English allows me to understand that “phoney war” means something like “not real” “fake” etc. So they were PRETENDING that they entered war as they promised. I am stand to be corrected on the language side.

JJSL:
Well, this just go’s to show how well Propaganda works , they were fed [zb] and we were fed [zb]
and what’s really funny, they are still giving all of us BS and it’s the Germans who are still way out in front of everyone !!!

That’s a good observation, the truth is allways somewhere in the middle. But you have to take into consideration, that we were fed with Soviet propaganda up to 1990, so after the changes there was a big overturn in Polish history teachings and everything. And because of that Poland was not allowed to tell the true, it is now very sensitive about the truth and I would say that they pay a lot of attention and try to stick to the historical fact as possible :wink:

welshboyinspain:
I’m with you on this one luke, any meal for the polish MUST include potatoes :laughing:

As a matter of fact it’s true that potatoes are very popular in Poland, but off course not every meal must include them. And it might be surprising for many of you, but average Pole consumes only few kgs more of potatoes per head that average Briton - the only difference is that we usually eat them just cooked, while you eat them mostly as chips, which is less healthly.

Ex Haulier:
Our polish friends were also good enough to provide a nice ghetto and some lovely holiday camps for our jewish friends.

If you blame Poles for ghettos, gas chambers and so on, you are proving that you are complete ignorant in history or that you just trying to offend me. There is a word providing a proper description of the person who behave like that, but then it will make more work for our oversensitive mods. So I will just say, that it starts with the same letter as ignorance and it sounds pretty much the same in Polish and in English.

switchlogic:
At this juncture I feel it’s my duty to raise the quality of Polish food issue…

That made me smile :slight_smile: Point taken, altough (see below)

welshboyinspain:
here we go again :unamused:
somebody criticises poland and orys gives us a 40,000 word response about history

\

It is not about criticizing Poland, it’s about facts. The subject drifted from the new train to “why the Poles are cheaper” and “is it fair that they are cheaper” and “how they dare to be cheaper” etc. I tried to explain reasons why we are cheaper and that this is not really at your expense, as if the playground was level, you would never able to get so expensive.

Off course I am using the Polish history, because I know it much better than most, if not all, of you, and i think the reasons for that it’s obvious.

You can try me and check if it’s only about defending Poland - if someone started the topic saying how brilliant Poland was in 1920 when it stopped Bolsheviks from getting west, I would put the same effort to teach you some not commonly known facts from our history about how we betrayed Ukraine (we did to them a similar thing to what you later did to us). Every country has some cards in its history of which it should be ashamed.

Even if Ex Haulier wasn’t such trying to make me angry (which failed, I don’t think I can get angry becaose someone makes idiotic statement on the internet) I could tell him the truth about the relations between Poles and Jews. The whole truth - about antisemitic movements before the word, about how many people helped jews risking their own lives under German occupations (see who have most , about that most of the people prefered just to worry about their own problems, as live under ■■■■ occupation was hard enough for them, and how the small minority turned against Jews (see Jedwabne for example: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jedwabne_pogrom ). As i said all nations have some dirty card in its history it should be ashamed of, and I am not going to hide them from you. But Poland was responsible for Holocaust as much, as Ex Haulier is responsible for AIDS epidemy.

robinhood_1984:

orys:
Yeah, but there is a third part of that story :wink: Lot of Polish/Lithanian trailers are now pulled by Russians and the sort :wink:

Can you explain the difference between a foreigner coming to live and work in the UK and a foreigner going to live and work in Canada?

I don’t understand it you see!

orys:
I have a few minutes, so I’ll try to answer to some questions:

robinhood_1984:

talk of Abbeville is irrelevent as it happened the year after Britain decleared war on Germany.

The Abbeyville conference took place 12th of September 1939, so 12 days after Poland was attacked.
So unless Britain declared war on Germany year before Poland was invaded, or unless you are talking about different Abbeyville conference, you just have no idea about what you are talking about.

I do appologise Orys, I had thought you were refering to the engagements between German and allied forces in Abbeville during 1940 prior to the evacuations at Dunkirk.
As for the rest of it, it is mere speculation and ‘what if’ type scenarios. History is what happened, not what could or should have happened and despite the outcome and long term consequences of WWII I still maintain that Britain entered the war to honour its treaty with Poland, Britain did not succeed in that task but that is the reason Britain entered. The fact that no British soldier was present in Poland to help with the defence is hardly suprising given the fact that Poland is beyond Germany, it took only 30 or so days for Germany to over-run and largely defeat Poland and in 1939 Britains land forces were very small in number and incredibly out-dated in weaponry etc. It may have been a phoney war on land at that time but it certainly was not at sea, the arena where Britain was historically at its strongest. Lets not forget that German U-boats were sinking British cargo ships from the very first day of the war and by 1941/42 Britain was very close to being starved of enough food to feed itself. You make it seem like Britain decleared war on Germany for show and then sat back while every one ate cucumber sandwiches and played cricket. Just because Britain was not occupied by Germany does not mean that Britain and British people didn’t make huge sacrafices from the very first day of the war. The battle of the atlantic was a very real fight and not what could be described as phoney, nor was the German bombing of British cities worthless of mention. We all know that collectively as a nation, no one suffered more so than Poland during WWII but to suggest that Britain is responsible for Poland being occupied by the Soviet Union and thus deserves this current economic situation in present times is quite ludicrous in my humble opinion. Blame the Soviet Union and United states as they were the main power brokers, especially from 1941 onwards when the US was oficially involved in the war.
It could have been worse Orys, think how the Czechs of Plzen must have felt when they were liberated by American forces, only to see them withdraw and be replaced with Russians due to political agreements.

Any way its all irrelivent of who’s to blame for what because the biggest irony of this whole episode is the fact that the train you mention that carries Polish products to the treacherous British is run by a German company. Make of that what you will.

robinhood_1984:
I do appologise Orys, I had thought you were refering to the engagements between German and allied forces in Abbeville during 1940 prior to the evacuations at Dunkirk.
As for the rest of it, it is mere speculation and ‘what if’ type scenarios. History is what happened, not what could or should have happened and despite the outcome and long term consequences of WWII I still maintain that Britain entered the war to honour its treaty with Poland, Britain did not succeed in that task but that is the reason Britain entered. The fact that no British soldier was present in Poland to help with the defence is hardly suprising given the fact that Poland is beyond Germany, it took only 30 or so days for Germany to over-run and largely defeat Poland and in 1939 Britains land forces were very small in number and incredibly out-dated in weaponry etc.

It’s interesting, because if we stick to facts, it’s true that Britain entered the war but they never really did much more until they were in danger themselves. And it’s not true that they were no match for Germans - in September 1939 even the French on their own were much more stronger than Germans on Western Front - since Germans were mostly busy with Poland, which took them much longer than they expected and give them much more losses then they estimated.

Germans admited during the Nurnmberg trials that altough they could easy smash Poland (or French, if they wanted) they were no match for all three of the sygnataries of the threaty nor in 1938, nor in 1939. They decided to attack Poland only becouse they had some intelligence signals from France that France is going to ignore it, and it was obvious that Britain will not go for it without them.

O, look, there is even a quote on that in English Wikipedia:
At the Nuremberg Trials, Alfred Jodl said that “if we did not collapse already in the year 1939 that was due only to the fact that during the Polish campaign, the approximately 110 French and British divisions in the West were held completely inactive against the 23 German divisions.”[3]

It may have been a phoney war on land at that time but it certainly was not at sea, the arena where Britain was historically at its strongest. Lets not forget that German U-boats were sinking British cargo ships from the very first day of the war

Very first day after you entered the war, you meant. AFAIK there was no British ship sunk on 1 or 2 september.

It is true, that you were involved in the sea war, that was a mistake on my part to ignore that fact. Yet is had to be told that Poland send a squadron of the Battle Cruisers to support you in case of war. It was very controversial decision, but it was taken on the grounds that we cannot stand alone against kriegsmarine, and since it’s unlikely that you would send some ships to Baltic Sea, it will be better for us to send you our ships than to have them destroyed.

Still though as for land war my point is valid: if you (and French) attacked Germans on the western front it would not only help Poland, but also prevent the whole world from the terrible 6 years of war, as Germany could be defited easly by all three countries together. But then, we go into the “what if” scenario as well, which brings us to the question what would Stalin do in that case etc… But you can agree what me on this one “what if” - if Germany was beaten in 1939, Britain would not be starving in 1942.

and by 1941/42 Britain was very close to being starved of enough food to feed itself. You make it seem like Britain decleared war on Germany for show and then sat back while every one ate cucumber sandwiches and played cricket. Just because Britain was not occupied by Germany does not mean that Britain and British people didn’t make huge sacrafices from the very first day of the war. The battle of the atlantic was a very real fight and not what could be described as phoney, nor was the German bombing of British cities worthless of mention.

Wee fully agree on that.

We all know that C ollectively as a nation, no one suffered more so than Poland during WWII but to suggest that Britain is responsible for Poland being occupied by the Soviet Union and thus deserves this current economic situation in present times is quite ludicrous in my humble opinion. Blame the Soviet Union and United states as they were the main power brokers, especially from 1941 onwards when the US was oficially involved in the war.

Well, the September 1939 is one thing, but the Yalta (known, as I just learned by checking some background in British literature as “Western Betrayal” is the second thing. And you would propably agree with me, that Churchill wasn’t there as a waiter. Off course it’s not only Britain to blame for that.

And it nothing about deserving or not. I am trying to point out that the situation in Europe which still heals its wound after being cut in half by the iron curtain is the reason for that and not different economical situation.

It could have been worse Orys, think how the Czechs of Plzen must have felt when they were liberated by American forces, only to see them withdraw and be replaced with Russians due to political agreements.

After all, they landed at the same car as we did, so I don’t think that makes a big difference.

Any way its all irrelivent of who’s to blame for what because the biggest irony of this whole episode is the fact that the train you mention that carries Polish products to the treacherous British is run by a German company. Make of that what you will.

Yeah. And what is even more fun at the same time a member of my family, who was a big speditor before the war and who lost everything during it and the Stalinist period and who is an old gentlemen living in a small house in Szczecin received a visit from young German gentleman who informed him that he is a descendant of pre-war owner of his house and is considering to sue him…

Lucky noone really takes this thread seriously after German Goverment backed his support for such claims after receiving an estimate of the value of damages they done to Warsaw with question who they think should be sued for that. But as you can see this 91 old gentleman from my distant family wasn’t too amused about the whole situation as well :slight_smile:

Ok, I wasted another 20 minutes, I am glad that we both learned something, after all this brings us closer by understanding each other, and I think this is what is a benefit of these discusions :wink:

Good night :slight_smile:

Orys is right!! Britain had “peace in our time” Chamberlaine waving a bit of paper about in 1939
Poland was piggy in the middle of the Dictators Hitler and Stalin.

Germany was well aware the Alliance of Britain and France was fractious at best! After all Hitler secretly and a little later publicly broke the Armistace treaty when he moved into Rhur and started building his Armed forces up and annexing Austria!
All major clues to future trouble! But not to the Liberals under Chamberlaine!!

Didn’t save Spain
:laughing:

Wheel Nut:

robinhood_1984:

orys:
Yeah, but there is a third part of that story :wink: Lot of Polish/Lithanian trailers are now pulled by Russians and the sort :wink:

Can you explain the difference between a foreigner coming to live and work in the UK and a foreigner going to live and work in Canada?

I don’t understand it you see!

in my experience I moved away from the UK for a variety of reasons mainly things that were wrong with the country that I didn’t like and I thought it would be better to try living somewhere else, we tried france first but my language skills weren’t good enough to find a job but luckily my spanish is better than my french.
my complaint (which most call me a bigot for but hey ho) is that I moved to a different country and adapted to that countries lifestyle, unlike certain eastern europeans in the UK
I work for the same as a spaniard so i’m not undercutting the money,
I contribute to the local economy and don’t send my money back home to a different country,
I speak the language so I don’t need special treatment in the traffic office or life in general,
I eat and buy the local food so I haven’t opened a food shop just for my countries tastes,
and finally I don’t go on and on and on about how wonderful my homeland, I’ve made my bed now I’ll lie in it.

welshboyinspain:

Wheel Nut:

robinhood_1984:

orys:
Yeah, but there is a third part of that story :wink: Lot of Polish/Lithanian trailers are now pulled by Russians and the sort :wink:

Can you explain the difference between a foreigner coming to live and work in the UK and a foreigner going to live and work in Canada?

I don’t understand it you see!

I work for the same as a spaniard so i’m not undercutting the money,
I contribute to the local economy and don’t send my money back home to a different country,

That is another bit I don’t understand, the Eastern European worker comes to Britain and undercuts the local wage, yet can still afford to send money back home :open_mouth:

As for importing foreign food, any Tesco or Sainsburys has an International sector to buy Thai, Indian, Chinese and African ingredients. Bloody hell they even had some Chorizo and Flies in my butcher yesterday.

welshboyinspain:
in my experience I moved away from the UK for a variety of reasons mainly things that were wrong with the country that I didn’t like and I thought it would be better to try living somewhere else

Similar to me, except that I had not too bad life in Poland, my reasons were mostly personal and not economical.

my complaint (which most call me a bigot for but hey ho) is that I moved to a different country and adapted to that countries lifestyle, unlike certain eastern europeans in the UK

Just like me and most of Poles and Czechs I know, unlike certains Britons in other countries :wink:

I work for the same as a spaniard so i’m not undercutting the money,

Just like me and most of Poles and Czechs I know.

I contribute to the local economy

Just like me and most of Poles and Czechs I know.

and don’t send my money back home to a different country,

Just like me and big majority of Poles and Czechs I know.

I speak the language so I don’t need special treatment in the traffic office or life in general,

Just like me and most of Poles and Czechs I know altough there is still big group of Poles who don’t speak English well, it’s simply I don’t mix with these people usually.

I eat and buy the local food so I haven’t opened a food shop just for my countries tastes,

What’s wrong with this? If someone opens shop selling his national food? He runs his business here, pays taxes here, don’t ask for benefits or any other help, contributes to the economy… At the same time, people have more choice. Believe or not, but in the Polsih supermarket where my friends work, Britons are more than a quarter of customers.

And by the way: it is amusing to hear that foreign food is wrong from the member of the nation where the favourite meal is Curry and most food outlets sell Pizza and Kebab (correct me if I am wrong, but neither Pizza, Curry nor Kebab is a meal native to UK :wink: )

and finally I don’t go on and on and on about how wonderful my homeland, I’ve made my bed now I’ll lie in it.

Just like me. Except that you don’t need to defent your homeland all the time, since it’s not seen by your new hosts as a second category, retarded state :wink:

I told that several times - it is very nice country (ask drew128 if you don’t believe me), with lot of good things in it. Just like every other country.

I can’t be arsed to do all that quote crap orys so here goes,
firstly curry was invented by the british not the indians as in india most food is dry.
as for all your answers to my points you obviously don’t know many other polish truck drivers?
you say that they work for the same and not undercutting, what about the 300ish at nolans who replaced the irish and brit drivers for half the wages?
as for contributing to the local economy and sending money back home i know of many drivers who do european work mainly bulgarians and romanians who live in their truck for months on end and earn a pittance while sending whatever they can back home so how is that contributing to the local economy?
they don’t invest in property and pay a mortgage, they don’t buy a local car and pay tax on it, the list goes on and on but yet again you are wearing your rose tinted glasses and can’t see that certain people from eastern europe are like parasites on society, maybe its just that you and the poles and czechs you know obviously aren’t included in my wide ranging bigotted view

Wheel Nut:
That is another bit I don’t understand, the Eastern European worker comes to Britain and undercuts the local wage, yet can still afford to send money back home :open_mouth:

I think there are two things coming into it:

  1. Eastern Europeans despite popular myths do not work for 2 quid per hour. They aren’t idiots, if they can earn the same money than local people do, why should they agree to work for less?

As I propably mentioned on Trucknet already, the only case of someone offering to work for less I ever hears was a Scottish driver who was on the job interview with me and when he saw that he has no experience compared to me, offered to work for “50 less per month than me”.

  1. Eastern Europeans have much more experience to live in tight budgets. They put much more thought into how to spend their money and they have different priorities.

I’ve been to one working class pub last weekend. It was full and very busy, drinks were poured all the time. And from what I could hear from the table next to me was a conversation how you can’t make decent life nowadays on your wage even if you support yourself with benefits.

I was there with a bunch of Czech people, and last thing you can say about Czechs is that they do not enjoy spending evenings in their hospoda’s :wink: Yet they were shocked wondering “if they don’t have money, why they don’t just stay home”? It’s the same in Poland. If Polish people are short with money, they don’t go to the pub.

I think (correct me if I am wront) it’s because when for Polish people going out to the pub is a special occasion, not an everyday activity, pubs are so deeply rooted in British culture, that for many people it is almost as a second home.

These are cultural differences which make Eastern European style living cheaper than British.

Other example is that many Polish people cook at home from scratch, I know some Britons do that as well (for example our very own switchlogic, as I learned from another thread) but when you are in supermarket here and see what people have in their basket and compare it to what people have in their baskets in Poland or Hungary, you will see, that here people are buying much more ready meals.

Also: Polish people are used to that they have to do everything on their own around house or car. So they spend much less on tradesmans.

So this is not really the miracle. it’s just the way how you spend your money.

I know how they can afford to send money home, there was a couple of houses for rent in new ross many years ago and the poles rented them at the going rate, the thing is though they were sleeping 3 or 4 to a room and sharing the expenses whereas the likes of the brits would prefer to have a 3 bed house for man and wife with 1 or 2 kids they live like rats

welshboyinspain:
firstly curry was invented by the british not the indians as in india most food is dry.

Yeah they invented combination of all these Asian spices. Still, it is just a variation on the Asian kitchen.

as for all your answers to my points you obviously don’t know many other polish truck drivers?

I can bet that I know more than you :slight_smile:

you say that they work for the same and not undercutting, what about the 300ish at nolans who replaced the irish and brit drivers for half the wages?

I don’t know any working for Nolans, but these who I know don’t work for the half of the wages. I am in UK for 6 years now, and if I wanted to work for half the wage they pay to Britains, I would be never able to make the minimum wages. :stuck_out_tongue:

as for contributing to the local economy and sending money back home i know of many drivers who do european work mainly bulgarians and romanians who live in their truck for months on end and earn a pittance while sending whatever they can back home so how is that contributing to the local economy?

Well, not much, I suppose. Just as the Britons who do the same for Dutch companies for example (or, believe or not, for Polish, I already met two Britons driving Polish trucks, and I wasn’t looking).

they don’t invest in property and pay a mortgage, they don’t buy a local car and pay tax on it, the list goes on and on but yet again you are wearing your rose tinted glasses and can’t see that certain people from eastern europe are like parasites on society, maybe its just that you and the poles and czechs you know obviously aren’t included in my wide ranging bigotted view

there are such people in every nation, so if you take YOUR rose tinted glasses off, you will find Britons working for Dutch companies, Irish working for British companies and Britons working for Irish companies without contributing to the local societes as well. There are some even here on this forum.

You are right though, that I don’t stick to the parasites (nor British, nor Polish, nor Czech), but I had a mispleasure to work with them when I was an interpreter, and I was as outrageous on some of these Polish muppets here as you are, if not more. But, saying that, thanks to my bigger than yours knowledge of the Polish community, I can tell that percentage of the people you are talking about is much smaller than you think. If I was you, I would rather worry about this Benefit culture amongst yoru own countrymates (or rather I should worry of that, because I pay my taxes in UK, you no longer have to, beint settled in Spain) :grimacing:

welshboyinspain:
I know how they can afford to send money home, there was a couple of houses for rent in new ross many years ago and the poles rented them at the going rate, the thing is though they were sleeping 3 or 4 to a room and sharing the expenses whereas the likes of the brits would prefer to have a 3 bed house for man and wife with 1 or 2 kids they live like rats

I shared a flat twice during my stay in Scotland, First time it was the two scottish lads, who took the third one and placed him on the coach in the living room to “put the rent down”. I was not happy with it, so I moved out.

Second time was with two nice English girls, who now moved out to live 5 girls in a three bed flat. I moved out as well, and I have studio just for myself.

See, this is a good example: you heard some story from many years ago, and you think that this is a norm. No, it’s not. Take your grey-tinted glasses and look at Poles as a normal people. They are not rats, they are people like you or me, and they want to leave in civilised conditions. Actually this topic is amusing for me as average Polish flat is much bigger than British and all Poles I know complain about how small flats are here in UK :wink:

orys:

robinhood_1984:
If the UK had of lived up to even less of its commitments 60 years ago Poland would not even exist. Funny that you say you fought for Britain in he war, I see to think that Britain fought on behalf of you?! You may have lived for 50 years under Soviet rule but the alternative was German rule and I dont think 4 or 5 years of German occupation was going too well for you, never mind 50 years of it.

I know you like to think you saved the world alone, but closer look into history books should show you that despite Britains joined war on paper, the serious fightings never started until it was attacked by Germans. And then you had Poles flying your fighters for you…

Somehow I never heard about British soldiers defending Poland in 1939…

You were a great imperium, you ruled the world. This should not only give you profits but also responsiblities. You turned your back on Czechoslovakia in Munich, when Hitler invided Poland you just vawed your finger saying “bad, bad Hitler”, then when you got in trouble yourself, you kindly accepted help from Eastern European soldiers, you let them sacrifice their lives in Battle of Britain, protecting the convoys on Atlantic, in Africa, pretty much at every front, then in Yalta, when you no longer needed them, you turned your back at them again.

If you know the history, you would know how close you were to see how the German occupation feels on yourself, so you should not underestimate sacrifice of 1000s of Poles, Czechs, Hungarians, Yugoslavians etc.

Argument about “we joined war for you and then Hitler attacked us because of that” is not valid - Hitler would not bother if you declared war on him or not. He had a treaty signed with Soviet Union and yet he attacked it. So you would be in trouble anyway.

You had that chance in 1939, but you didn’t wanted to die for GdaÅ„sk. The French invided Germany and despite having more troops than ■■■■, they stopped, then in Abbeville you agreed with them that you would not provide any significant military help to your ally, Poland. It was a huge mistake, as you shoudl crush Hitler when he was busy fighting Poland on the Eastern front. Instead of that you let him do his job, and year later your soldiers arm in arm with ours were dying for London as Hitler attacked you having most of his army available for this task and being able to use Polish resources against French and then you.

I am not seeking revenge here, it is all history. But this history, as we can see, have long time repercusions and we can feel its results even now. I don’t blame you for that off course - most of you weren’t even born at the time.

But it would be nice, if you for a change looked at this from non-British perspective. I guess this is hard to Britons, hence all these situation when someones “forgots” the role of Poland - such as the Enigma code thing. For years and years Britons did not wanted to admit that the code was broken by Polish mathematicians as early as in 1932 and all know-how, algorythms and mechanical computers were given to Britain and France in summer 1939… Obvviously it was making a scratch on the way you liked to look at yourself - as someone who got to war for Poles and saved the world with a little assistance of USA. Do you know that it was not before 1968 when Britain finally admited that Poland had “some involvement” in breaking the code and it was not before 2000 when Britain admitted that job was done solely by Poles. It took few more years for Enciclopedia Britanica to change it there…

In meantime there was the movie “Enigma” when the only Pole was a traitor. Somehow the screenwriters “forgot” that the real traitors were for example Kim Philby and John Amery and none of them, as you can guess, was Polish.

There is many of such examples - you propably are not aware about them, but for obvious reasons Poles are very sensitive and polish foreign ministry always tries to make the things straight. But who cares about some minor notes in The Times or Guardian - most of public opinion is based on what they learned in school and on things like this infamous “Enigma” movie.

And to make it clear: I am not willing to say any bad world about all this British men and woman who gave their lives during the war. I just think that if the allies did not made a mistake of abandoning Czechoslovakia in 1938 and Poland in 1939, there could be less victims in every of our nations.

But off course the politicians of the time did not knew that, and in order to save the peace (at least for their own country) they did everything to actually avoiding going into the open war with Hitler for as long as possible. And I don’t blame them for that.

But the threaty between our countries was broken. First time in Abbeville, when allies after advancing a few kms into Germany decided to withdraw. And second time in Yalta - when Churchill broke the word given to Sikorski about Poland’s future after the war. This are historical facts.

I can fully understand that you don’t like them. But this is how the things were. It is now history, so don’t worry, noone will sue you for damages or hate you for it. It is the past, we have now the common future to build and current problems to worry about. But it is important to remember the history as it was, to be able to uderstand it’s influence on present times, and also to avoid the mistakes. The old saying says “the victourios write their own history”. You can say that for Poland the war ended in 1991 when the last of the soviet troops witdrew from our country. So now we are victourios as well, so let’s just agree on some common verision of the facts.

Orys, we are in the middle of remembering the terrible losses suffered in two world wars. You’re making me feel we shouldn’t have ■■■■■■■ bothered you ungrateful ■■■■■ I’m getting royally ■■■■■■ off with your Polish hard luck story about how we abandoned you. God I wish the ■■■■■■■ Russians were still in charge!