Wiretwister:
ralliesport:
We are all human beings we are devided into different groups because of age, gender, who our parents are, where we live, what out genetic makeup is the possibilities are endless and of course people like that, some because they think they belong to a wider group and feel safe, that is nature but dubious. Others like it because they can exploit it to their own advantage, either to exploit a group or destroy a group. They also do it to keep them down or make them fight amongst them selves like Saddam.
Who says a British identity is the answer. Im pritty sure alot of people would resent being called european, I certianly would. Being Irish, Scottish or Welsh seems to be no problem (although I think very few of them have been born outside of these countries) being english seems to be a problem although 90% of the population is. British is the easiest identity to be assumed by the widest population without much argument.
An interesting conclusion but from the evidence of my own eyes and experience I arrive at an altogether different view. We are all human beings you say and with that I agree. However to suggest that we are divided into seperate groups is a nonsense unless that specific difference is directly related to the scenario. For example a mother will likely have a greater insight into child bearing than most fathers. Why because their experiences can not shared only related. To the point in Bulldogs original post the job of driving a truck can be done by anyone with the appropriate skills. Gender, nationality religious practice are irrelavent.
So lets explore the second paragraph:- It was my interpretation of your previous post, the one I quoted originally, that you were advocating every one should have a British identity no matter what. Now my geography may be a litle rusty but last time I looked Britain was part of continental Europe which is part of planet Earth. If you find that you get some added comfort by “tagging” yourself as British fine but how would you define being British? Our head of state (Queen Elizabeth 2) is less British than I because I can trace my ancestry back 6 generations with people born in this country. Go back further and you will see that the Romans, French, Vikings, Germans have all influenced Britains development over the past 2000 years or so.
However you choose to label yourself I doubt that you are any different to MOST other people in the world, be they French, Russian, Mexican, Afghan or Chinese, who simply want the means to provide for themselves, their families live at peace with their neighbours and let them do the same.
I dont believe people are seperated into their own groups. There is no reason to be seperated. I Believe people like to be in there own group through choice rarther than need. To be with your own kind and feel safe, that no one (should) take advantage of you or risk youre place. This I feel is just natural, but it can & will be overcome eventually. It will take time for everyone.
British. Well if you can trace your ancestry back 6 generations your ancestry would not have lived in a country called Great Britian. Our country has been influenced by many cultures, by many peoples. Afterall it is probable that most of the english race now came over here and drove the origional inhabitants into wales. Immigrants have come over here throughout the centuries and Im proud they have come over here and out country has prospered and they have prospered. Our langage is a version of a old german language. The romans intorduces us to many industrial ideas and we introduced much of the modern technology to the world.
Just out of interest what do you concider yourself?
I concider myself british, many others do (my grandmother is german). Geographically, yes we are on the contenental plate of europe. But you try telling the Irish republicans that we are both the same because we live next to one another, do you think they will agree? You define other people French, Russian, Mexican, Afghan or Chinese how? where they live, where they were born, what language they talk? you presumably define them somehow? if there is to be no british would you say people are defined from which tectonic plate they live on? or are we all just human with no division which is what Id like. Afterall if there is to be a French, Russian, Mexican, Afghan or Chinese surely there has to be a british?
Oh yes russian & afghan live in peace hmmmm… not what Ive heard funnily enough