jonnytruckfest:
I understand what you mean Lucy, I suppose with this being my first time trying to get some form of article printed I’m going to make a lot of mistakes ( I usually do anyway!
) But it’s all learning curves that I have to take in order to get somewhere.
My first feature was a commissioned piece on the history of transport cafes on the A1. I was given 1500 words, and did it whilst I was on maternity leave as a way to boost my income. The first attempt turned out at 8000 words. Then I cut it to 7500. By the time I’d got it down to 6000 - so still 300% overlength - I had no idea what else to do, and Dave said to send it in and he’d try and advise (fortunately there was no deadline, it was an open-ended thing as a first go). I was utterly convinced it was perfect, and taking out so much as another syllable would ruin it.
It came back at bang on 1500 words with a note attached saying “Compare and contrast. Dave.”. After picking myself up off the floor and consoling myself over the loss of my “brilliant” work, I started on what was to be a very steep learning curve, one I’m still on to this day.
I have a copy of that piece somewhere, both the original and the edited version. He was right. It was crap. 
I have a feeling that Chris might think I am a bit of a nob with trying to dig my heels in to say I was right but I admit I was wrong in trying to prove someone who does the job professionally wrong
I just hope it doesn’t cloud his judgement of me as I just felt a bit let down with an idea I believed would be a great one for the mag.
No offence, but what would be great for the mag is not something you could possibly know. You don’t understand length issues yet, you haven’t got your head 'round the fact that printed media isn’t the internet and space is at a premium, and you don’t yet understand the pressures editors are under from many, many different directions to produce a closely-defined finished product.
I am stubborn so admitting I am wrong is like trying to take sweets from a kid
And I’m just letting him get on with what he needs to do and I hope it’s done well (Probably better than I expect!!) I wouldn’t mind having a mentor and being able to have some bits in magazines as I’m all about sharing my work with the world I must admit
And it’s a way of me becoming an established photographer in the process as that’s where I would like to be, usually when I have my mind set on something I never stop until it’s done which I know can work both ways
I just have to hope I get there 
You get a mentor by showing raw talent. If someone thinks you’re worth mentoring, they will approach you and say so. In the meantime, be prepared for a lot of rejection, and to admit you’re wrong over and over and over and over again. If was easy, any bugger could do it, and they can’t.
The biggest thing is to remember is it’s not about what you think or what you want to write, it’s about what the editor thinks, what he wants you to write, and how many words he wants you to write it in.For example, I’ve got a small feature about different wages schemes in CM this week. It was torture trying to find company directors willing to talk AND get examples of 4 different ways of paying AND interview and then quote those people in a way that wasn’t just a list of facts, showed some of their character using their own voice, and made both interesting and coherant reading AND add a legal section, all in 1000 words. To a deadline. But that’s what I’m paid for.
And don’t worry about the typos it took me 2 goes to crack English myself so I have no room to grumble about typos

That was a tongue in cheek comment. I’m used to sub-editing my own work, so the typos were the first thing to come out of the post. Had it been for print, about half the words would’ve come out next, including nearly every instance of the word “that” and anything that could be shortened by use of apostrophes. Good grammar, vocabulary and use of punctuation are vital.
It’s all just a waiting game now to see what the article looks like. 
It always is. You’ll know you’re getting somewhere, however, when your main concern is simply whether it’s been printed so you can invoice for it and get paid a month later! 