It is all a game:
They want to extract as much money from us for the least return possible
We want to pay the least possible for the maximum cover.
The rules of the game are fairly clear - Give them all the information they ask for and DON’T tell lies.
Playing the game is more complicated:
First decide what cover you need. This is not as simple as you think.
‘Comprehensive’ doesn’t mean what it used to mean and may companies don’t offer TPT&T anyway.
Roadside assistance? You may already have it from elsewhere (your bank account may have it included)
Annual mileage? (look at your last few MOTs to see what you actually do).
Windscreen cover used to be standard but is often extra now. Check the price of a windscreen for your car to see if it’s worth the extra.
Excess. You should probably choose the maximum possible and make sure you have that much money available in case you need it.
Other drivers. The history of other drivers on your policy will affect the price you pay and this can be used to your advantage. My 24-year-old daughter puts her mother on her policy, even though she may never actually drive the car, and this reduces the cost by as much as 10%. (This is perfectly legal).
How you pay. Many, but not all, insurance companies charge extra for paying monthly.
NCB protection. Protecting your no claims discount which may well be six or eight years and 60% or more may look well worthwhile, but it only works as long as you stay with that particular company and we all know that we should shop around every year.
The obvious way to keep future premiums down is to make no claims. If you make a claim (or even report an incident without making a claim) they will increase your premium the following year, and this would apply even if you change insurers. If you are in a collision with no casualties then take loads of photographs - the cars and the people - that keeps them honest. Try to negotiate a settlement without involving the insurers since that will increase everyone’s premiums.