In respeonse to Steven Ladymans comments in the page quoted below, I’ve fired off the following e-mail. Anyone want to do the same?
Dear Sir,
From the BBC Article: BBC NEWS | UK | England | Kent | Lorry drivers protest over hours
You are quoted as having said: “There are certainly some people who aren’t implementing the directive properly,”
Are you actually aware that the directive has done NOTHING to reduce actual working hours and has only meant an increase in the amount of paperwork for a driver.
When the WTD was introduced to haulage, there was a concession to the bosses in the form of the Period of Availability (PoA). This covers, in some sectors of haulage, over 50% of a drivers daily duty time. Some absolute genius decided to legislate the WTD so that PoAs and driving breaks are not classed as working time.
So lets take a look at a working day:
Pre WTD:
Driver starts at 6am. Drives 2 hours to a supermarket RDC. Gets on a loading bay, sticks the tacho on other work whilst getting unloaded which takes an hour. He drives 2 hrs back to the depot and has a 45 minute break. He then spends an hour with the tacho on other work whilst he gets reloaded. Again he drives 2 hrs to a supermarket RDC, gets on a loading bay, sticks the tacho on other work whilst getting unloaded which takes an hour. He drives 2 hrs back to the depot, fuels up and finishes his shift at 6pm.
Total hours worked that day: 11.25.
Post WTD:
Driver starts at 6am. Drives 2 hours to a supermarket RDC. Gets on a loading bay, sticks the tacho on PoA (because thanks to the definition of a PoA, it is now classed as a PoA instead of other work) whilst getting unloaded which takes an hour. He drives 2 hrs back to the depot and has a 45 minute break. He then spends an hour with the tacho on PoA whilst he gets reloaded. Again he drives 2 hrs to a supermarket RDC, gets on a loading bay, sticks the tacho on PoA whilst getting unloaded which takes an hour. He drives 2 hrs back to the depot, fuels up and finishes his shift at 6pm.
EVEN THOUGH HE HAS DONE THE SAME 12 HOUR SHIFT, only 8.25 hours count as work towards the 48hr weekly limit under the WTD rules. Nearly a third of his hours don’t count.
What should have happened is that the PoA should never have been introduced and the working time counting towards the 48hrs a week been classed as duty time, INCLUDING driving breaks. After all, you may not be doing anything but you are still at work and driving breaks could be abused to keep the hours down.
Please could you respond with your views on this?
Yours truly,
Conor Turton