Shame these meaty balance sheets don’t reflect on staff wages eh?
A change in the nature of insurance will be a game changer in the entire distribution industry, and will affect strong-balance sheet companies as much as weak ones. In fact sheer complacency will see strong firms under-react when the “insurance crunch” comes, maybe as soon as next year.
Manville were effectively brought down by asbestos claims which they couldn’t get paid off by any insurances. The went into voluntary bankruptcy.
The company still exists, but is now owned by Buffet’s vehicle Berkshire Hathaway. Shareholders lost their shirts.
This only happened because the insurance wouldn’t pay out/wound’t cover the claims made against the company.
Sooner or later, someone is going to sue John Lewis or TkMax or some other large apparently immortal firm, and they may or may not survive it when their insurances don’t pay out for some newly invented (or old established!) reason.
BP are paying out billions, but have even MORE billions, and thus will continue to survive. John Lewis & TKmax on the other hand are only worth about £5bn for the former, and around £15bn for the holding company of the latter. BP have already budgeted more than the entire value of each of these firms for the gulf cleanup alone.
What would happen if a fire at a tkmax warehouse caused hundreds of rich people to be killed by say, a poison gas cloud (like Bhopal) that drifted to some affluent area some distance away from the warehouse (which presumably won’t be in a posh area)?
For John Lewis, say an improperly vetted worker (hired to save money) starts a bombing campaign among their stores? It’s all buried whilst the company and the security services attempt to clean up from within. BUT by the time it’s sorted, hundreds have been killed, and then the scandal that the firm knew all along and didn’t warn the public comes to light… Lawsuits that will easily strip bare the so-called “strong balance sheet” I would estimate, especially if the victims include rich Americans who’ll be chasing punitive damages in the tens of millions EACH!
It’s all about unlimited liabilities. The future won’t be the same as the past is what I’m saying. Even the biggest most solid companies can be brought down by a “black swan” event.
Firms can tread the working class underfoot as part of their business model maybe, but once the ruling classes themselves find their own kith and kin start to become the firm’s victims, we might see a different outcome to systemic fat-catting and corner-cutting to make that extra bit of profit.
The recruitment process at too many large firms today is about getting ‘any-old-staff for less money’. ‘Quality staff for more money’ doesn’t compute. That will come back one day and bite them in the arse I’m sure.
Finally, it has to be said that John Lewis have debts the same as just about every other firm out there - at quite a high interest rate too!
Are they as solid as everyone thinks?