Mazzer2:
Rjan, yes the soviet workers had rights, the right not to travel, the right not to criticise their government, the right not to have free and fair elections they lived in a dictatorship. If the Soviet model was so good why was the Berlin wall built? The numbers leaving this utopian workers paradise were so great that the only ones that would have been left in East Germany were the Stasi.
I would not cross a picket line if the dispute is about pay or conditions however if it is a political strike then I would have no qualms about crossing it
You’re making the error that I’m promoting the Soviet model, when what I’m really doing is merely challenging your propaganda about it.
The Berlin wall was built for a number of reasons. Firstly, the East of Germany was yoked to a regime that was far less economically developed overall, whereas the West of Germany was yoked to the most developed capitalist nations.
Secondly, the West offered inducements - actual reward money - for people to flee into West Germany, and West Germany itself received economic largesse like Marshall Plan money that was specifically designed to undermine the Soviet regime.
The numbers who wished to leave East Germany are probably not dissimilar to the number of Brits who would leave if somewhere more economically developed than Britain existed (especially if they speak the same language at the destination), or if somewhere more unequal than Britain existed and they stood to be on the better side of the inequality.
Millions fled Britain in the post-war years, and so many were carpetbagging to Southern Rhodesia that the British government eventually imposed a travel ban. The Rhodesian government itself also imposed travel bans and capital controls designed to stifle emigration. These were all capitalist regimes, of course.
As for “criticising the government”, try criticising your boss in public, and see what sanctions follow. Look also at what happens to democratically-elected politicians like Corbyn, who challenge bosses’ rule - smeared publicly as a Russian spy and Stasi agent, all of which are absolutely truthless.
One last thing, I’ve got far more respect for someone who crosses a picket line for some genuine political principle, than one who sees it simply as an opportunity for personal gain, the latter of which is totally reprehensible.