Best car recovery to use?

Have used AA , RAC , Green Flag and Autonational.

Had one recovery with Autonational and service excellent . Only other times I have called out recovery is for a flat battery . Have two policies as I also keep a car in Ireland . I believe the AA are much more thorough in their work than Greenflag or Autonational ( who use contractors ) . For a flat battery , Greenflag and Autonational just jump start you , whereas the AA do a full check on your battery and check that it is actually holding the charge . AA far to expensive but will usually price match or you can use Daily Mail discount points or Quidco . Both RAC and AA will attempt to repair , contractors just recover .

N.I Express:
Have used AA , RAC , Green Flag and Autonational.

Had one recovery with Autonational and service excellent . Only other times I have called out recovery is for a flat battery . Have two policies as I also keep a car in Ireland . I believe the AA are much more thorough in their work than Greenflag or Autonational ( who use contractors ) . For a flat battery , Greenflag and Autonational just jump start you , whereas the AA do a full check on your battery and check that it is actually holding the charge . AA far to expensive but will usually price match or you can use Daily Mail discount points or Quidco . Both RAC and AA will attempt to repair , contractors just recover .

you should complain to your breakdown club if you get poor service from a contractor .as part of there contract they should give the same service as A.A or RAC.We attend all breakdowns with a service van and have a 80% fix rate :smiley:

r627higg:
We attend all breakdowns with a service van and have a 80% fix rate :smiley:

There are lies, there are damned lies & then there are statistics.

It is not possible to fix 80% of ALL breakdowns with a service van. It might be ‘just’ about possible to fix 80% of those jobs that a service van is sent to, but to claim that 80% of ALL breakdowns can be fixed roadside is bovine excrement.

This is where the big clubs go horribly wrong IMO. They have monkee’s in their call centres.

If I phone up & attempt to explain that my lower left flange coupling bolt has sheared off & shattered the peripheral diaphragm, leaving all my oil + half my bottom end on the road behind me, they will still send a service van !

Dave the Renegade:
I’ve been with the AA for forty years.When you get your quote haggle on price,if you get a cheaper quote from RAC,tell the AA and they will match it.

So, on this basis, my quote of £38 from AutoAid will be matched by the AA ?

Comparing the AA to the RAC is like comparing a rock to a hard place.

If any of you are driving Volvo cars (and I think Ford do it as well) look into the Assistance scheme offered by the dealers. By having mine serviced by a main dealer I got breakdown thrown in, a quick comparision showed the same cover from the AA would have been £101, so take that off the service price (Which actually wasn’t a lot more than a none franchise garage) and it works out well.

Plus it’ll be recovered to a main dealer, not just a local spanner monkey.

Paul_Humphreys:
I am with rescuemycar.com/breakdown/ but I have never had to call them out so can not say how good they are.

Paul

You must drive a Honda then :slight_smile:

dew:
If any of you are driving Volvo cars (and I think Ford do it as well) look into the Assistance scheme offered by the dealers. By having mine serviced by a main dealer I got breakdown thrown in, a quick comparision showed the same cover from the AA would have been £101, so take that off the service price (Which actually wasn’t a lot more than a none franchise garage) and it works out well.

Plus it’ll be recovered to a main dealer, not just a local spanner monkey.

Had a value service on a car which I keep in Northern Ireland . Not a big fan of Ford Main Dealers but as the value service was only £125 and included recovery and homestart decided to try it . Excellent value and standard of service good too . Have the choice of AA or RAC if the car breaks down as also I have personal cover on any vehicle in the mainland

Chas:
This is where the big clubs go horribly wrong IMO. They have monkee’s in their call centres.

If I phone up & attempt to explain that my lower left flange coupling bolt has sheared off & shattered the peripheral diaphragm, leaving all my oil + half my bottom end on the road behind me, they will still send a service van !

There’s a good reason for that.
You’d be amazed how many times a customer tells me a gearbox has packed up, and I find a ball joint on a gear cable popped off, roadside repair.
Customer tells me the DPF light has come on, the car’s gone into limp mode and needs to go to a dealers. I use the Texa to do a forced re-gen, roadside fix from me.
There’s a water leak from the car, it’s under warranty so needs to go to the dealers - aircon condensing. No fault found.
Transit van running rough and won’t rev. Needs to go to the garage. I fit an EGR valve - roadside fix.
Customer tells me the immobiliser has lost it’s code and needs reprogramming. I find the wire off the starter motor, another roadside fix.
Customer says they’ve got a flat and they havn’t got the locking wheel nut key. Needs recovered to QuickFit :unamused: . Easy roadside fix.
■■ me, last week a guy said his headlights had been getting dimmer and dimmer, to the point they are next to useless. That says to me it’s an alternator fault. I carry a couple of common alternators on the van. I go in the van anyway (as we’re instructed to do). Turns out the feckwit was driving with his sidelights on, headlights were switched off. And it wasn’t the case that his headlights were getting dimmer and dimmer, rather the sun was going down and the sky was getting dimmer and dimmer. He was well chuffed when I switched his lights on.

If we recovered everything the customer says needs recovery, we wouldn’t need a service van, just more recovery trucks.

The best ones are the non-starts in the pub carpark at 11.30pm. If I stay there all night I get that motor running, just to prove I’m not a bleeding taxi service for ■■■■■■ drivers :laughing:
Usually there is a relay or fuse missing. And for some reason, the customer seems ■■■■■■ off that I’ve fixed it :slight_smile:

Chas:
It is not possible to fix 80% of ALL breakdowns with a service van. It might be ‘just’ about possible to fix 80% of those jobs that a service van is sent to, but to claim that 80% of ALL breakdowns can be fixed roadside is bovine excrement.

Chas I dunno where you get your facts from, but an 80% fix rate is achievable. Especially on heavies, where recovery is the last resort. This is nothing to do with fiddling statistics to make things look good, there’s a very easy formula.
How many breakdowns are passed to me? How many of those are fixed? What is the fix percentage?
See, no need to be an accountant to work this out.
Take this from someone who runs an independant breakdown recovery company.

In fact, as it happens I’ve just been going through the other shifts job sheets for the last 5 days. For the 30+ service van jobs we’ve attended over the last 5 days, 1 got recovered, and that was a shredded clutch on a Stralis.

Chas:

Dave the Renegade:
I’ve been with the AA for forty years.When you get your quote haggle on price,if you get a cheaper quote from RAC,tell the AA and they will match it.

So, on this basis, my quote of £38 from AutoAid will be matched by the AA ?

Comparing the AA to the RAC is like comparing a rock to a hard place.

Not at all.The RAC quote that I got for the same types of cover was a £120 cheaper tan my AA renewal quote,who when I told them I was leaving them,they matched it.This has happened the last two years.

Dave the Renegade:
Not at all.The RAC quote that I got for the same types of cover was a £120 cheaper tan my AA renewal quote,who when I told them I was leaving them,they matched it.This has happened the last two years.

So . . . If your RAC quote was £120 cheaper than your AA renewal, then that renewal must’ve been a pretty sky high price?

If this has happened for the last 2 years, you must be paying £1000’s out for your breakdown insurance !

How much of your hard earned £money are you chucking at the AA?

What business is it of yours?

Chas:

Dave the Renegade:
Not at all.The RAC quote that I got for the same types of cover was a £120 cheaper tan my AA renewal quote,who when I told them I was leaving them,they matched it.This has happened the last two years.

So . . . If your RAC quote was £120 cheaper than your AA renewal, then that renewal must’ve been a pretty sky high price?

If this has happened for the last 2 years, you must be paying £1000’s out for your breakdown insurance !

How much of your hard earned £money are you chucking at the AA?

It was a quote for over £200 for several types of cover and associate membership.If you read the post properly I didn’t pay it.There is no way I would pay thousands.but If you broke down a long way from home and paid a garage to fetch your vehicle back, it would cost much more than £120.
Go and teach your Granny to ■■■■ eggs. :laughing:

Dave the Renegade:

Chas:

Dave the Renegade:
Not at all.The RAC quote that I got for the same types of cover was a £120 cheaper tan my AA renewal quote,who when I told them I was leaving them,they matched it.This has happened the last two years.

So . . . If your RAC quote was £120 cheaper than your AA renewal, then that renewal must’ve been a pretty sky high price?

If this has happened for the last 2 years, you must be paying £1000’s out for your breakdown insurance !

How much of your hard earned £money are you chucking at the AA?

It was a quote for over £200 for several types of cover and associate membership.If you read the post properly I didn’t pay it.There is no way I would pay thousands.but If you broke down a long way from home and paid a garage to fetch your vehicle back, it would cost much more than £120.
Go and teach your Granny to ■■■■ eggs. :laughing:

Forgive me if I have this all totally & horribly wrong . . . but are you now paying £80 for a level of cover that should cost £200?

Chas:

Dave the Renegade:

Chas:

Dave the Renegade:
Not at all.The RAC quote that I got for the same types of cover was a £120 cheaper tan my AA renewal quote,who when I told them I was leaving them,they matched it.This has happened the last two years.

So . . . If your RAC quote was £120 cheaper than your AA renewal, then that renewal must’ve been a pretty sky high price?

If this has happened for the last 2 years, you must be paying £1000’s out for your breakdown insurance !

How much of your hard earned £money are you chucking at the AA?

It was a quote for over £200 for several types of cover and associate membership.If you read the post properly I didn’t pay it.There is no way I would pay thousands.but If you broke down a long way from home and paid a garage to fetch your vehicle back, it would cost much more than £120.
Go and teach your Granny to ■■■■ eggs. :laughing:

Forgive me if I have this all totally & horribly wrong . . . but are you now paying £80 for a level of cover that should cost £200?

I am quite happy with what I am paying.I know you work or do work for another organisation.But it is a free country and we are able to chose who we go with. I will stay with the AA because they have treated me fine when I have needed them.
Are you a Jehovah’s Witness,because you are about as persistent as them.

Always have been with Britannia, great service, can’t complain,

I’m with Europ Assist through Adelaide Insurance. Had to call them out a year ago - petrol Mondeo was struggling to make progress. Called them out and the local agent confirmed my thoughts -coil pack (common enough on Mondeos). Got put on a recovery truck and recovered to their local depot (won’t name them or the area!, but they were very friendly, helpful and quick) where we were transferred to a bigger truck and new driver. He showed me a second hand coil pack he had in the truck - he would have fitted it and charged me £25 for the part. I would have been home a couple of hours sooner and he could have gone home to bed. But his bosses insisted he took us home as they stood to make more from the recovery than the repair. I should have thought to suggest he fitted it and told them he had taken me home - we all win!! Always an expert in retrospect!
In fairness Europ Assist were very good and the initial attendance was quick.