Confusion with hours etc

LazyDriver:

Franglais:

LazyDriver:

ROG:
You do not need 45 mins of WTD breaks before 9 hours if the shift is longer than that
Example - 12 hour shift with 11 hrs + 15 mins working time
Work 4 hours
Drive 2 hours
15 break
Drive 2 hours
Work 2 hours
Drive 30 mins
30 min break
Drive 1 hour
Work 15 mins

I think this example is wrong. You’ve needed to have taken another 15min break before 9hrs work for wtd. (which wouldn’t count towards your tacho break, as being the second break needs to be 30mins for tacho break)

If the shift was ending at 9hrs that would be true.

But here because the shift extends beyond 9hrs the driver is taking his other breaks later on.
Ever seen examples where breaks need to be taken just before the end of a shift, then followed by one minute of work?
Crazy, but thems the rules.
.
I’ll stand correction on that though.
.

I’m going to go for the correction choice.
This is how I understand it…
I agree with the silly ‘can’t end on a break’ rule though

I see nothing that contradict Rog’s example.
His driver takes 15min before 6hrs.
And 45min before shift end. (Shift over 9hr)
He doesn’t exceed 6hr without a break.
.
.
Yes, he goes beyond 9hrs on only 15min break, but that doesn’t seem to actually be a problem, as the further break is taken before the shift ends.
I assume this where you see the problem?
Common sense says it’s a problem, but the rules, as I read them, don’t.
.
Ed. Written at same time as last post by LazyDriver